



We have resolved the majority of our bugs and the site is taking shape.Student project for Online engagement. Case study of Pick n Pay




We have resolved the majority of our bugs and the site is taking shape.

Here is a visual idea of how to go about card sorting
This is a list of website URLs that PnP currently has online. These sites come up on the first two pages on Google when typing “Pick n Pay Websites” I also explain each URLs purpose and function according to PnP.
wwwpnp.co.za
This URL leads you to the main site intended for all users to go to. This site is the ‘Mother site’ for all the URL’s on the net. This site represents PnP holistically, which means that a lot of it’s success relies on how it captures the overall physical image and communicates it online.
www.pnponline.co.za
This is the official online shop. This can also be accessed from the pnp.co.za website. The site allows the user to register shop for products and services online. The site uses elements of the new brand identity and design. It could do better by minimizing the amount of content clutter making it more efficient to use (as mentioned in our business objectives).
www.cycletour.co.za
This website shows event info, travel, sponsors, media centre and gallery to document the cycle tour challenge hosted by Pick n Pay. Form first glance the site looks and feels up to date with what’s happening this very instant. There is a timer on the top left counting down the days, hours and minutes to the next cycle tour. This creates anticipation for anyone using the site. On the homepage there is a Latest News section, a Sponsors section, and a blog section where people have the freedom to comment on previous and future events
The site however doesn’t fit into the design frame which PnP is building on with this new image. The main site PnP.co.za has a completely different structure to this one as well. When rolling over buttons and reading content has no similarity to the mother site. But it does work well as a stand-alone website.
This site has information about the different marathons that are held annually by Pick n Pay. On this site they show race details, results, entry procedures and rules. It also gives info on the map route. The site serves as an information roster for people who want to take part in the event. My immediate criticism with the site is that the information hasn’t been updated. The banner on the top right corner shows a marathon commencing on February the 15th 2009. It also doesn’t have any photos or videos that can help sell the event further.
www.pnp-ir.co.za
this URL links you to the financial and Corporate sector of the Pick n Pay brand. It has info on financial results and share prices, corporate profile, and news and media comments. The site keeps an archive of annual reports, sustainability reports and minutes from their annual General Meetings (to name a few). This site is good for letting the consumer know exactly where and how the profit made by PnP is spent. The site works by showing the brand’s transparency. It creates more trust for the brand and paints a positive and honest picture for PnP.
www.gobanking.co.za
This URL is a link from the online shopping site. The site contains information on credit card, account details and assurance details. The site has an interesting homepage that caught my attention straight away. The use of vibrant moving buttons adds an exciting visual contrast to what the content of the site offers. What I like about this site is that is lets you know how safe and secure it is to shop using Go Banking.
www.picknpayentertaining.co.za
This URL links you to shopping for party and entertainment platters for all types of events over the net. It is also available on the online shopping site under the department’s category. The site is useful in offering this service online.
Conclusion
The URL that stood out for me was the Go Banking one. This site works because it has a vibrant rather than static style and approach which would encourage me to come back to it. The least favourite URL is the PnP marathon one. Here there is no sign of updated info, and the site doesn’t make you want to get involved.
This is Pick n Pay’s lifestyle magazine. It offers a wide variety of articles focused on healthy living, the magazine features recipes, feedback on recipes and competitions, a puzzle and brain bending section for adult, and a children’s fun and games section. The website currently has one static banner ad for the magazine which doesn’t capture the user’s attention.
The magazine can become part of the site, it can be added as a new button and page section altogether. Users can subscribe to the magazine online, and information and articles could be presented in an online format.
Whilst these are all great community events as well as charity driven, the online presence does not do these great initiatives any justice and can help drive the online shopping site.
Currently the sport links on the Pick n Pay home page give little information or link to a new URL with race information and details.
What the company has somehow forgotten along the way is the fact that athletes require specific diets as well as nutrients and vitamins. All of which is available in store. These athletes will train all year round and at the very least one month before a race.
Having trained and entered competitions myself I know what a pain keeping a good diet can be. It is tough to find out which products are good vs bad and good advice on the subject is often extremely costly.
So why not offer a section on the online shop that blurs the barrier between the event and shop. We could structure the section so that a cyclist for example can click on the 'sport shop' and choose to have a grocery list created that will include all of the ingredients they need for their meals for that week.
The same could be done for all of the varios sport and lifestyle options that Pick n Pay is involved in.
We could also attach maps of training routes in the surrounding area of the customers nearest Pick n Pay store.
These features if constantly updated with current events can create user return and increase user interaction on the site.
User experience design
This is an analysis of the user experience for the PNP website using the user experience honeycomb.
Useful
The site is useful in terms of delivering on its basic purpose, it offers shoppers the opportunity to shop online rather than going to the physical shop.
Usable
The site does have its flaws in terms of usability. As been explored on the user test where we found that to complete an online task such as filling up a shopping cart takes three times more the amount of clicks in comparison to one click from its competitor Woolworths. The idea is to fix the problem by making the categories more understandable first for instance, re- arranging the items within the categories to match the basic flow and location of where to find them in the store.
Desirable
The site makes use of Pick n Pay’s new image and design with the use of round edged frames on banners and headings. Also the colours match to the colour scheme of the logo.
Findable
Given that the Google ad word for PNP online comes first on the Google page when typed shows that the findability of the site is easy to find. Then there are the shopping categories when doing your shopping. There is a repetition of headings under which to find shopping items. For instance under cheeses, you have more than one heading to find the processed cheese rather than having all processed cheese under one category. This creates confusion when buying your cheese.
Accessible
The site has a basic HTML design which makes it easily accessible to most computer browsers. The site doesn’t however have accessibility to people with disabilities such as blindness.
Valuable
When looking at the how Pick n Pay positions itself, they try to promote healthy living and lifestyle which is not entirely explored in the way the user interacts with the site. This could make users question whether the brand has made a successful change in image.
credible
Since there is no clear indication of updated information (such as notifications or RSS feed), the trust for the information given on this site will be based on how well the user knows the product they are purchasing. There is little detail given to describe the item you purchase which creates a lack of trust.
Navigation Patterns
The Navigational patterns that I found were the following:
* All-in-one
* Flat
* Index
* Hub-and-spoke / Daisy
* Strict hierarchy
* Multi-dimensional hierarchy
* Search
Current pattern (advantages and disadvantages)
The current pattern which has been used by Pick n Pay would be a combination of All-in- one and strict hierarchy pattern. The site has a system whereby the main homepage elements stay constant as you click through the other pages. In some instances such as the viewing of shopping items, all the categories and images pages are placed alongside each other and are accessible through
Ones that would work for Pick n Pay
A Multi-dimensional hierarchy would work for Pick n Pay because this pattern makes use of more hierarchies which are laid over each other. This could make the shopping list simpler to navigate through.
Another pattern would be the daisy (or hub and spoke) model where the pages are interlinked on a system where you go back to the main page once you have found and placed your order.
Heuristics for Woolworths
This is a look at the competitor Woolworths Design heuristics using the
The site could have considered putting a time display to show the user that the site is current recently updated. The site also doesn’t have a loading bar or page to show loading time, so the user must guess how long its going to take to get page content fully loaded.
The system makes for more information to be available to the user that would often be hard to find in store.
The user is able to look through lists of items just by doing a roll over on the main buttons. This makes it easier to find what you are looking for. There is also a quick link section that helps make it easier to find sections under the heading you've chosen. One thing that doesn’t work is the number of menu bars there are on the homepage. There are three horizontal menu bars that can confuse the user on which one is the main bar and which ones are sub-menu bars.
The site makes use of simple labels and text font for their buttons to make it simpler to communicate. They also have a quick link menu (which PnP don’t have) to show links to all the most used pages and info.
Error prevention
The site has no errors that I could see after an hour of using it.
Recognition rather than recall
The site doesn't show any sign of remembering that I was on it. So I have to learn how to navigate through it all over again.
Flexibility and efficiency of use
Since it is quicker to find and order an item on this site, there is a good amount of efficiency. We have found through testing that it has a 3:1 click ratio to Pick n Pay. This means people are spending less time clicking through information on this site.
The site makes use of highlighted words that link you to other bits of information. These act as extended buttons linking you to information without having to always go to the top menu buttons. This works in some instances but it is an over use of links at some areas. For instance, when you want to find out more about Credit Card Info. There is a button on the menu that takes you there, there is no need to give extra links to Credit Card info.
The site makes sure that you don’t run into errors that easily. The only error recovery area I came across was when I was filling in my login info. Here when i made an error on my username, password, and account number, the site showed a footnote (text written in red) with a list of all errors made.
Help and documentation
There is a way in which Woolworths has considered this. By showing an explanation for each of the headings you may choose to go to. When going to credit for instance, there is a box which contains details on the buttons that you are about to enter.
I will be analyzing the PnP website using Norman’s 7 principles to good user interface design. These principles (developed by Donald Norman) show and evaluate ways in which the site could work better for novice and expert users.
Visibility
The idea is to see (plain and simple) the instructions and how to go about doing the task without having to read the instructions physically. When looking for an item on the site, the viewer must be able to understand where to get the item. This means understanding that each name stands for the particular item. When looking for details on food catering for parties, I the user didn’t know that this information would be under Entertaining. It should be under Catering services or Party planning. The site should make it so that the viewer must know where to find certain sections rather than assume them.
Feedback
Feedback on the site makes it so that the user doesn’t get stuck on what action has been taken. This is helpful when the user wants to go back on a decision or pre-determine the function before doing an action. The site has quick response when looking through the pages.
Constraints
The scroll bar on the side of the site when looking through products becomes an immediate constraint. This puts off people because it is painstakingly long to look for a product or item when having to scroll down to the bottom of an html page. The solution would be to have a scroll down page within the main page to keep the rest of the page static, so the user doesn’t have to scroll up again.
The site has been laid out using all-in-one user-friendly navigation structure. They put all the content on the homepage, so when clicking through different pages, the buttons and the homepage menu stays the same.
Consistency
There is an inconsistency in the way the content is presented under the different sections. For instance, under General Merchandise is countless confusion on where to find certain products. The heading is too broad for the items under it. This heading should have been split into more than one category to clearly define the kind of items found there. There are also no images for some items on the shopping lists, and some recipes don't have an image.
Affordability
The layout of the buttons doesn’t show that the function is to roll over the buttons for drop down menus to appear. The user has to assume that this function is available. There is also far too many menu bars which are not placed well in order of hierarchy.
Error coding
Since I never ran through any technical problems when going through the site, I believe the site has done well in keeping this problem at a minimum.