I will be analyzing the PnP website using Norman’s 7 principles to good user interface design. These principles (developed by Donald Norman) show and evaluate ways in which the site could work better for novice and expert users.
Visibility
The idea is to see (plain and simple) the instructions and how to go about doing the task without having to read the instructions physically. When looking for an item on the site, the viewer must be able to understand where to get the item. This means understanding that each name stands for the particular item. When looking for details on food catering for parties, I the user didn’t know that this information would be under Entertaining. It should be under Catering services or Party planning. The site should make it so that the viewer must know where to find certain sections rather than assume them.
Feedback
Feedback on the site makes it so that the user doesn’t get stuck on what action has been taken. This is helpful when the user wants to go back on a decision or pre-determine the function before doing an action. The site has quick response when looking through the pages.
Constraints
The scroll bar on the side of the site when looking through products becomes an immediate constraint. This puts off people because it is painstakingly long to look for a product or item when having to scroll down to the bottom of an html page. The solution would be to have a scroll down page within the main page to keep the rest of the page static, so the user doesn’t have to scroll up again.
The site has been laid out using all-in-one user-friendly navigation structure. They put all the content on the homepage, so when clicking through different pages, the buttons and the homepage menu stays the same.
Consistency
There is an inconsistency in the way the content is presented under the different sections. For instance, under General Merchandise is countless confusion on where to find certain products. The heading is too broad for the items under it. This heading should have been split into more than one category to clearly define the kind of items found there. There are also no images for some items on the shopping lists, and some recipes don't have an image.
Affordability
The layout of the buttons doesn’t show that the function is to roll over the buttons for drop down menus to appear. The user has to assume that this function is available. There is also far too many menu bars which are not placed well in order of hierarchy.
Error coding
Since I never ran through any technical problems when going through the site, I believe the site has done well in keeping this problem at a minimum.
No comments:
Post a Comment