In this evaluation I will unpack whether the site is effective and where it falls short.
We will also be doing this process for a top competitors site.
1. Visibility of system status
On the Pick n Pay site I found one area when it was necessary to show the system status.
This was on the online shopping portion of the site.
Once you choose a department and the three category boxes appear a notification of loading... is shown. This is sufficient for a faster Internet connection, however on a slower connection the word loading... is not sufficient. I feel that it is not sufficient as the type and .... are stagnant. Their should be a loading bar or movement of some sort to indicate that something is happening and there is no room for concern.
There is also a lack of feedback. once you click on a department within the shopping site there is no indication that you have entered the department with the exception of the page header. This forces the user to have to remember which department they are in which is not clever design. A potential fix for this could be to utilise a breadcrumb navigation style that reminds you of the process you have gone through to get to a point. A site that uses this effectively is kalahari.net
2. Match between system and the real world
The first point that the site does not deliver on as far as what the user expects can be found on the Pick n Pay homepage. The button Kitchen leads users to a page for cooking classes and recipes. We could at a push see what the designer was thinking, however a consumer visiting a grocery stores web page will not associate these things with 'kitchen'. In the same way a person looking for cooking classes and recipes will not automatically associate kitchen with the things that they are looking for.
Secondly the navigation button order is not what the user expects. The current order is; Kitchen, About us, Investor relations, Health and nutrition, Sport, Envirozone, Shopping.
A more logical order for the user could be; Shopping, Kitchen, Health and Nutrition, Envirozone, Sport, Investor relations and About us. I feel that this is a more effective order because the primary function is shopping, then lifestyle and finally information about the company that is specifically sought by a specific type of person.
A third problem is that the navigation buttons move on a mouse over showing that they are functional, however only work if the user clicks on the type within the buttons. There is no excuse for this as all that is needed is a larger hit area.
Then there is the unforgivable mistake. The shopping button on th main navigation bar does not even take you to the online shopping portion of the site but rather to information about shopping online. The users instinct is that this button would take them to the online store.
On the online shopping portion of the site the department buttons have no synergy with the PnP homepage buttons. Users expect a site to have synergy and this is not apparent fron the department navigation bar.
3. User control and freedom
The user has the ability to control what they do on the Pick n Pay site in general, however the one thing that it lacks is an in sit back, or previous stage function. The only way to go to a previous state currently is by using the browsers back function. I feel that the inplementation of this function 'an emergency exit' could improve usability.
4. Cosistency and standards
I have covered this topic with connection of the words on the buttons kitchen, and shopping. These buttons do not meet the coventions of what the user expects. If the user has to wonder what the outcome of a click will be the designer has not done their job correctly.
One other area that this happens is where a user clicks on the flowers and gifts department. When you click on any of the other department buttons you are able to view products through the three category boxes. However with the flowers and gifts button you are sent to the netflorist site. This can interfere with a users online shopping experience and is unexpected. A fix for this would be to exclude this button from the department navigation and rather include it as an ad or link.
5. Error prevention
So far I have been unable to get an error on the site and therefore feel that currently th site has been successfull in error prevention.
6. Recognition rather than recall
The site lacks recognition on where the user has been on the site. The user is required to recall what the process is of getting to the desired product. This could be improved if their was a bar that shows you the last 10 viewed items or your most viewed items, so that you can quickly access them.
7. Flexibility and efficiency of use
Accelerators for expert users is apparent on the online shopping site. I feel that this is working to some degree as your previous shopping carts can be saved and accessed when you revisit the site making the use site better for expert users. Another function that could be used to help this process along would be to create a reoccuring shopping bag that is preordered on a weekly basis so that the user does not have to constantly place new orders.
8. Aesthetic and minimalist design
It is apparent that the designer/s have tried to create a minimalistic design however it is apparent that this has not been very successfull. Theis is alot of clutter and unessesary information on the site. For instance on the homepage for Pick n Pay their are 13 links other than the navigation buttons that pertain to many different parts of the companies offerings. This could be resolved by only including additional information thet is relevant to the portion of the site that is accessed.
The design should be consistand with the companies corporate identity. However there are too many differences between the different URLs such as the navigation bars.
9. Help users recognise, diagnose, and recover from errors.
As far as I cansee this has been done successfully. When I tried to add something to my shopping cart without being logged in I was not met eith an error code, but rather a message that stated that I needed to log in to the site or register before I could order.
10. Help and documentation
under the callcenter number there is a comprehensive instruction documentation link.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
No comments:
Post a Comment