Friday, May 29, 2009

New PnP Information Architecture



Here are some visual representations of our revised IA for the PnP main page.

Wednesday, May 27, 2009

Example of new IA and start of wireframes


More card sorting




General Update

Just an update on what we have been working on recently.
We completed all our new site maps using the card sorting method, which we found very effective as it is easy to identify problems as well as re-order the information by forming new clusters. We believe we have come up with the most efficient solution for the Pick n Pay website.
We are now finishing off our wireframes, after deciding on the navigation and layout we will use.
Next its on to creating these wireframes in Dreamweaver, and then it will be time to start some basic design ideas and compile our improved presentation for Monday.

Wednesday, May 20, 2009

New IA through Card cluster

Today we managed to create what we believe is the most effective Investor relations Information Architecture. Tomorrow we will tackle online shopping.
Here are some pics of the process.




Tuesday, May 19, 2009

Tuesday 19th May

Just to keep the blog fully updated... our task for today is to create cards for all the categories for all pick 'n pay websites, so that tomorrow we can begin our card sorting process, and from this construct our information architecture based on the new clusters.
Here is a visual idea of how to go about card sorting

Card Sorting
This is a task whereby a set of tasks (or functions) are written on separate sheets of paper, then put down in no particular order, then a group of people (focus group) must un sort these tasks. The group consists of six or more informants who form part of your target audience and they must assign each of the tasks into separate groups or clusters. The results from this testing will help in configuring the tasks statistically and therefore help in structuring the information accordingly.

An example of how my group could use this method is because we want to re arrange the categories for the online store from departments to individual stores, we want to be able to group all the products into their suitable categories. This will minimize the consumer’s chances of getting lost looking for a product in another category, which was one of the major issues in our user testing. The idea then is to write out the new categories which we decide are the best for the products to fall under, sit with the informants and look at where each of the products land up.

The main idea behind card sorting is to figure out how the user expects the website information to be laid out and presented, which information is to be grouped with which, and what hierarchical order is best to present this information. Which in turn helps us the designers structure the site more efficiently and user friendly.

Reference:
www.usabilitynet.org/tools/cardsorting.htm

Monday, May 18, 2009

Project Plan


This is an outline of the time we estimate we will spend working on each task, and when we think these tasks should be completed by in order to give everything sufficient attention, without negelecting or rushing any sections. Time management is essential in huge tasks such as these as well as co-ordinating the group.

Revised Strategy

We have compiled a strategy that if implimented
correctly will create a formidable online offering that will beat the competition.

1. Structure
• We would like to incorporate the Go Banking site as an integrated portion of the store , as this is a valuable services available in store.
• We will reduce the amount of clicks required to complete any given task through creating well ordered clusters of information.
• We will reduce the advertising clutter, and allocate the right right navigation bar as advertising space as currently advertising and PnP website links are clustered together, which is very confusing for users who
are then uncertain of the results they will get when clicking a link.
• We will combine the main PnP site with the online shopping to create a consistency of design which will be closely informed by the Pick n Pay brand identity. This design will be in line with the new identity.
• We will remove Gifts and Flowers from the online shopping as it is a link to
an external site, which is misleading for the user, and instead promote
Netflorist within the designated advertising space on the site.
• We will reduce the amount of scrolling required by the user as this can becoming frustrating, we will use a “mini-box” which scrolls, or page numbers to solve this problem.
• We will use a saturated navigation system that is in line with our new Information Architecture.
We plan to do this as it is extremely successful for larger sites that sell items online such as Amazon and Kalahari.
• A breadcrumb navigation will be utilised so that the user always knows exactly where they are within the site. Breadcrumbs will help by remembering where the user is so that they don’t have to.
• We will create 2 URL’s – one for corporate and one for the main
PnP site with all the other URLs incorporated into it. This will be the most effective solution as it will reduce the time spent trying to manage separate websites. We feel that it would not be
effective to try and fit this into one URL as the corporate information is so vast that one URL will not be able to cope.
• We will implement a Multi-dimensional navigation hierarchy as it would work for Pick n Pay because this pattern makes use of more hierarchies which are laid over each other. This pattern has been used successfully on online shopping sites such as Amazon.com
We
would like to incorporate acommunity programs feedback page, as well as an option to search for
and participate in events in your area. This would assist Pick ‘n Pay inmeeting its objectives of benefitting communities and help people engagemore with their brand.

2. Naming
• We will refine the search function on the online shopping site based on our new Information Architecture.
• We will make clearer categories, through revising the grouping and wording of certain categories. We plan to create understandable groupings of products.

3. Features
• We will create an option to upload photographs, have them printed and delivered with online shopping items.
• Pick n Pay radio will be streamed on the website as an optional function to encourage engagement with the brand.
• We suggest that a portion of the profits from online shopping be donated to charity and advertise this fact, as we this would increase people’s willingness to shop online and boost Pick n Pay’s image as being a caring organisation.
• Airtime will be included in online shopping, it is available in-store, and is easy to incorporate.
• There will be a product image for every product on the online shopping site, as consumers need to see what they are buying.
• Every product will include adequate information, descriptions, as well as nutritional values. Our observations show that people often read the packaging of products before purchasing items.
• We will create a list of the last 5 or 10 viewed item for the online shopping section to assist with recognition and recall for the user.
• We will create a recurring shopping bag which will assist the regular user, who might want certain essentials to be delivered routinely.
4. Integration
• Incorporate Fresh Living Magazine in our online strategy as an online magazine, as well as creating
specials which are only available online.
• We are focusing on marketing a healthy, holistic lifestyle as PnP’s USP.
We will incorporate various existing elements of the site into one comprehensive lifestyle section on the main site, which will also be integrated with the online shopping. An example of this integration could
be that recipes for training cyclists can be easily added to the user’s shopping basket. We can also include training routes for cyclists and athletes that are in the surrounding areas of Pick ‘n Pay stores. This will
create better interaction and repeated visits to the site by the customers.
• We will combine all the environmental information and initiatives into one section, as we believe it is an important part of Pick n Pay’s marketing strategy and is becoming a topic which is increasingly
relevant to users.

5. Feedback
• Customer service and response are crucial. We aim to reduce the customer feedback complaints by creating a dedicated section for customer feedback on the main PnP site which is easily locatable and has
a dedicated team running it, in order to respond to all submissions timorously.
• All feedback for the users will be made active rather than static, e.g. the loading bars. This will reduce confusion for the user who might assume that nothing is happening due to a static image.

If this strategy is successfully implimented we believe that a true reflection of what the brand stands for will be achieved. The site will be user friendly and customers will want to engage with the site on an ongoing basis.

Phase 1 Feedback

We presented the first phase of our assignment today.

The general feedback was good, however one or two problems where identified.

We need to refine our presentation design.
We need to go into more depth with our navigation evaluation.
We need to refine our strategy.
We need to go in depth with our IA moving forward letting it determine our navigation style based on the category clusters.

Saturday, May 16, 2009

First Presentation on its way

This weekend is all about refining our research into a comprehensive and professional document that will show our research and strategy proposal for Pick 'n Pay online. We will also be creating a flash presentation and doing preparations for this presentation.

Sending a question or complaint

For any online site the speed of response to customers questions is key to creating an online experience that is comfortable for the user.

We sent in a query to the Pick 'n Pay help center about an issue relating to registering to the online shopping portion of the site.

We are still waiting for a response after 5 days, however the issue has resolved itself.
Regardless of the fact that the problem has been solved a response to the email that we sent is needed.

This problem is reinforced by the information gathered from the Hello Perter site graphs.

Friday, May 15, 2009

Pick ‘n Pay site map insights

These are some insights taken from analysing the site map of Pick ‘n Pay as well as all related URLs.

• The “Kitchen” button is misleading. Perhaps it could be renamed as “Recipes”.
• The order of the main home page buttons is confusing.
• The entertaining section is found in the Kitchen section but also under online shopping, which does not make sense. The Kitchen section contains recipes; therefore the entertaining section should only be located as a category within online shopping.
• The “About Us” section is comprised of company information, which is probably only viewed by a select few user seeking specific information. It may be best to group this information with the other company information such as financial reports.
• Environmental and social initiatives are found in the About Us section, which many users may not look at. They should market these things more – making them more visible and accessible will promote their brand more.
• The Health and Nutrition section mainly contains recipes, along with some advice. Perhaps this could be combined with the recipes from the kitchen section into a new category.
• The sports section is mainly comprised of external links. This makes it difficult for the user to navigate the pages and find information. Combining these into one comprehensive sports section on the main website would be more effective and user friendly.
• The main site often repeats links to certain things. This repetition should be eliminated as it creates clutter and is confusing. Also, links and advertising are sometimes located in the same place which creates further confusion and clutter, and should also be eliminated by keeping advertising and the website relevant links separate.
• The Envirozone should include the company’s environmental initiatives instead of just providing information relating to environmental issues. The sustainability report (which is currently a separate URL) should also be included in this section. This will make everything easy to locate and serve as a USP for the brand.
• The entertaining section links to an external website. This is not an optimal solution as the user may want to purchase everything at once; therefore it should be incorporated fully into the online shopping.
• The Flowers and Gifts links to an external site, which could be annoying or confusing for the user. It would be best to include this as an advert or a noted external link and not as part of the online shopping, as the netflorist site requires a separate purchase anyway.
• The Go Banking link is very hard to locate. It is currently found under “Contact Us” on the main site. This problem should be remedied as it is a selling point for Pick ‘n Pay to have these additional services and should be easy for the user to find and access.
• The “Contact Us” only has an online query section. This does not make it clear as to whether the consumer can make complaints here etc. This should be made more obvious, or a different option should be made available for complaints and compliments.
• The link to help find missing children should be incorporated into a section instead of “floating around” where people are unlikely to access it.
• There is an external link to find careers at Pick ‘n Pay stores. Perhaps an employee section could be introduced.

Pick ‘n Pay Investor relations site map insights

• Separate sections for Pick ‘n Pay Stores and Pick ‘n Pay Holdings are scattered throughout various sections in this website. A solution to this could be creating two main sections of the website for these separate organisations.
• As previously noted, the sustainability report is external, and should be incorporated.

Pick ‘n Pay Sports site map insights

• These are spread across several URLs, with scattered information. All of the sports pages should be combined into one comprehensive sports section within the main site.
• One gallery should be formed for each sport with different subsections for the events.
• The Pick ‘n Pay cycle tour blog links to the cycle tour main website for most information requests, which makes it seem useless.

Online shopping site map insights

• Under the beverages section, the grouping seems random within some third level categories.
• The entire cheese bar section’s categories and subcategories are confusing, for example options for processed cheese under most sections, as well as a main processed cheese section.
• The title “Chilled Foods” is a confusing category name, and yoghurt should not fall under this category but be grouped within the Dairy category.
• There is a groceries section within the main groceries category, which could be confusing. The sections under here could be rearranged into clearer categories.
• The Kitchenware section should not fall under groceries as it contains things such as cutlery and crockery etc.
• The “Body Paint and Tattoos” section under make-up and hosiery should be removed as nothing is in it other than pantyhose, which should be in the pantyhose section.
• Perhaps make-up should not be under groceries as it is not an “every-day” or very frequent purchase for most people.
• The shopping bag section is empty, which should be remedied.
• Crackers etc should not be filed under “biscuits”, as this is confusing or misleading and makes these products difficult to locate.
• Some category options are repetitive to fit into the three tier navigation on the current site, which is unnecessary and can become annoying for the user.
• Some categories list all the brands, for example shampoos and conditioners. It can become quite annoying to scroll through all of these options.
• Maybe items can be arranged by popularity instead of in alphabetical order to reduce scrolling or searching for most users.
• The name “General Merchandise” may confuse the user about what falls under this category – it could be separated into smaller and more obvious categories.
• The wine and liquor section is confusing, as wines are located in both the liquor and the wine sub-sections. This must be revised so that wines fall into one section.
• Gifts and flowers links to netflorist, which is an external site and therefore shouldn’t be part of the online shopping as this is misleading, therefore is should just be advertised as an external link on the site.
• The entertaining website is external but should be incorporated into the online shopping site.
• The donations should possibly be removed from online shopping.
• Recipe centre on the online shopping site and the recipes of the main site should be combined, and both should then have the option to add the ingredients to the shopping basket.
• The Go Banking link should the more visible.

Thursday, May 14, 2009

Woolworths insights

Woolworths Main headings that run across the top of the page use copy that appeals to the user in that the words explain what to expect when you enter the page as as being inviting.
The main page of Woolworths website is structured, well layed out and uses minimal amount of text allowing users to easily read the main points displayed on the page where as Pick n' Pay have too much information on their home page that is slightly too much to bother to read. Woolworths invites the user to see there specials and see what is going on rather than forcing information into the face of the online user.

Viewing the product list on the Woolworths website is quite a difficult task. Two clicks have to be made before finding the product list and it is not immediately noticeable to the user where the link is not big enough nor in the correct placement where a user would automatically look. Pick n' Pay works slightly different where it took three clicks to find the product list and made use of a different url linking to a new page. This is not good. Like Woolworths, Pick n' Pay's product list is also difficult to find at first on the page. Pick n' Pay's navigation is not very clear when it comes to finding specific products and the different navigation bars make it even more difficult to navigate. Woolworths keep all there products on a single list with a second navigation bar that drops down from the previous list. This makes it easier for the user to navigate through the list and retrace their steps.

Woolworths lists the all the information including ingredients and a picture on their products once they have been selected , where Pick n' Pay just show a picture and the name of product. Woolworths have added more value to their users where they can check the ingredients and know exactly what it is they are buying.

Woolworths Identity and business objectives run through out their site in information and design where as Pick n' Pay's site is too confusing and shows too many things not creating synergy.

Online Presence for PnP’s existing URLs

This is a list of website URLs that PnP currently has online. These sites come up on the first two pages on Google when typing “Pick n Pay Websites” I also explain each URLs purpose and function according to PnP.

 

wwwpnp.co.za

This URL leads you to the main site intended for all users to go to. This site is the ‘Mother site’ for all the URL’s on the net. This site represents PnP holistically, which means that a lot of it’s success relies on how it captures the overall physical image and communicates it online.

 

www.pnponline.co.za

This is the official online shop. This can also be accessed from the pnp.co.za website. The site allows the user to register shop for products and services online. The site uses elements of the new brand identity and design. It could do better by minimizing the amount of content clutter making it more efficient to use (as mentioned in our business objectives).

 

www.cycletour.co.za

This website shows event info, travel, sponsors, media centre and gallery to document the cycle tour challenge hosted by Pick n Pay. Form first glance the site looks and feels up to date with what’s happening this very instant. There is a timer on the top left counting down the days, hours and minutes to the next cycle tour. This creates anticipation for anyone using the site. On the homepage there is a Latest News section, a Sponsors section,  and a blog section where people have the freedom to comment on previous and future events

The site however doesn’t fit into the design frame which PnP is building on with this new image. The main site PnP.co.za has a completely different structure to this one as well. When rolling over buttons and reading content has no similarity to the mother site. But it does work well as a stand-alone website.

 

www.pnpmarathon.co.za

This site has information about the different marathons that are held annually by Pick n Pay. On this site they show race details, results, entry procedures and rules. It also gives info on the map route. The site serves as an information roster for people who want to take part in the event. My immediate criticism with the site is that the information hasn’t been updated. The banner on the top right corner shows a marathon commencing on February the 15th 2009. It also doesn’t have any photos or videos that can help sell the event further.

 

www.pnp-ir.co.za

this URL links you to the financial and Corporate sector of the Pick n Pay brand. It has info on financial results and share prices, corporate profile, and news and media comments. The site keeps an archive of annual reports, sustainability reports and minutes from their annual General Meetings (to name a few). This site is good for letting the consumer know exactly where and how the profit made by PnP is spent. The site works by showing the brand’s transparency. It creates more trust for the brand and paints a positive and honest picture for PnP.

 

www.gobanking.co.za

This URL is a link from the online shopping site. The site contains information on credit card, account details and assurance details. The site has an interesting homepage that caught my attention straight away. The use of vibrant moving buttons adds an exciting visual contrast to what the content of the site offers. What I like about this site is that is lets you know how safe and secure it is to shop using Go Banking.

 

www.picknpayentertaining.co.za

This URL links you to shopping for party and entertainment platters for all types of events over the net. It is also available on the online shopping site under the department’s category. The site is useful in offering this service online.

 

Conclusion

The URL that stood out for me was the Go Banking one. This site works because it has a vibrant rather than static style and approach which would encourage me to come back to it. The least favourite URL is the PnP marathon one. Here there is no sign of updated info, and the site doesn’t make you want to get involved. 

Fresh Living Magazine

This is Pick n Pay’s lifestyle magazine. It offers a wide variety of articles focused on healthy living, the magazine features recipes, feedback on recipes and competitions, a puzzle and brain bending section for adult, and a children’s fun and games section. The website currently has one static banner ad for the magazine which doesn’t capture the user’s attention.

 Key insights

  • The magazine has cut out discount coupons which can be used in the store for discount specials.
  • The magazine is monthly updated with new recipes and nutritional info. Also this month’s issue has an article on African travel.
  • The overall design of the magazine serves as an extended brand contact point in which the identity and image of Pick n Pay are present.
  • When reading the magazine as opposed to going on the site, I feel more of a family orientated connection and emotion that draws my attention. Whereas on the site the feeling is mainly of business info and shopping.

 How it could be applied on the site

The magazine can become part of the site, it can be added as a new button and page section altogether. Users can subscribe to the magazine online, and information and articles could be presented in an online format.  

 Another way in which the magazine can work online is if the site were to have limited or exclusive vouchers and coupons that can only be accessed on the online magazine. This could bring more people to the site.  

 What works successfully on the magazine but hasn’t been explored on the site is the children’s section. It’s a clear way of capturing the mothers and identifying with the family aspect of the brand. This is something that the site is missing as mothers are the primary target market.

 

 

 

 

Wednesday, May 13, 2009

Giving back to the community

Pick n' Pay does many things to give back to the community as well as doing what is possible for helping the environment. Pick n' Pay has many initiatives regarding the environment where they create awareness for the community around them and incorporate an environmentally friendly way of running their shops in terms of power, material and element usage. The staff of Pick n' Pay are also educated on an environmentally friendly work place as well as what they can do at home to help the environment upon entering the Pick n' Pay team.

The life long bag is also part of Pick n' pay's initiative for the environment by selling environmentally friendly bags to customers so they don't have to buy plastic packets. a percentage from the 5 rand selling price goes to the Pick n' Pay enviroment fund.

As well as being green Pick n' Pay has done lot's for many different charities over the years and at the moment Pick n' Pay are aiding the "table of peace and unity" this is a nation wide event focused around bringing South Africans together for lunch to raise funds for many childrens funds.


Pick n' Pay are doing so much for the environment and community yet they do not nearly show this enough online. where they have small little print that does not attract attention they could have a page with in the site to show there initiative and be proud of it and show this to the consumer. At the moment it seems to be too hidden away and feels like it's only there because it has to be. This could also be regularly updated to show progress and let customers know they are making a difference.




www.underconsideration.com

Creating a unique selling point for Pick n Pay online

Pick n Pay is extremely active in sponsoring and creating sporting events.

They currently run or are involved in:

Cycling;
  1. PnP Fast One
  2. PnP Weekend Argus Rotary
  3. Knysna Cycle Tour
  4. PnP Hyper Tour
  5. D' Winelands Cape Argus
  6. PnP Cycle Tour
  7. Velokhaya
Cricket
  1. PnP Calypso Cricket
Running
  1. PnP Marathon
  2. PnP Cape Times Knysna Forest Marathon
Kids
  1. Cape Argus PnP Tricycle
  2. PnP Knysna Oyster Festival for the Young
Women's Golf

Race 4 Change

Paralympics

Whilst these are all great community events as well as charity driven, the online presence does not do these great initiatives any justice and can help drive the online shopping site.

Currently the sport links on the Pick n Pay home page give little information or link to a new URL with race information and details.

What the company has somehow forgotten along the way is the fact that athletes require specific diets as well as nutrients and vitamins. All of which is available in store. These athletes will train all year round and at the very least one month before a race.

Having trained and entered competitions myself I know what a pain keeping a good diet can be. It is tough to find out which products are good vs bad and good advice on the subject is often extremely costly.

So why not offer a section on the online shop that blurs the barrier between the event and shop. We could structure the section so that a cyclist for example can click on the 'sport shop' and choose to have a grocery list created that will include all of the ingredients they need for their meals for that week.

The same could be done for all of the varios sport and lifestyle options that Pick n Pay is involved in.

We could also attach maps of training routes in the surrounding area of the customers nearest Pick n Pay store.

These features if constantly updated with current events can create user return and increase user interaction on the site.


PnP user experience honeycomb

User experience design

This is an analysis of the user experience for the PNP website using the user experience honeycomb.

 

Useful

The site is useful in terms of delivering on its basic purpose, it offers shoppers the opportunity to shop online rather than going to the physical shop.

 

Usable

The site does have its flaws in terms of usability. As been explored on the user test where we found that to complete an online task such as filling up a shopping cart takes three times more the amount of clicks in comparison to one click from its competitor Woolworths. The idea is to fix the problem by making the categories more understandable first for instance, re- arranging the items within the categories to match the basic flow and location of where to find them in the store.  

 

Desirable

The site makes use of Pick n Pay’s new image and design with the use of round edged frames on banners and headings. Also the colours match to the colour scheme of the logo.

 

Findable

Given that the Google ad word for PNP online comes first on the Google page when typed shows that the findability of the site is easy to find. Then there are the shopping categories when doing your shopping. There is a repetition of headings under which to find shopping items. For instance under cheeses, you have more than one heading to find the processed cheese rather than having all processed cheese under one category. This creates confusion when buying your cheese. 

 

Accessible

The site has a basic HTML design which makes it easily accessible to most computer browsers. The site doesn’t however have accessibility to people with disabilities such as blindness.   

 

Valuable

When looking at the how Pick n Pay positions itself, they try to promote healthy living and lifestyle which is not entirely explored in the way the user interacts with the site. This could make users question whether the brand has made a successful change in image.

credible

Since there is no clear indication of updated information (such as notifications or RSS feed), the trust for the information given on this site will be based on how well the user knows the product they are purchasing. There is little detail given to describe the item you purchase which creates a lack of trust.

Navigational Patterns

Navigation Patterns

The Navigational patterns that I found were the following:

* All-in-one

* Flat

* Index

* Hub-and-spoke / Daisy

* Strict hierarchy

* Multi-dimensional hierarchy

* Search

 

Current pattern (advantages and disadvantages)

The current pattern which has been used by Pick n Pay would be a combination of All-in- one and strict hierarchy pattern. The site has a system whereby the main homepage elements stay constant as you click through the other pages. In some instances such as the viewing of shopping items, all the categories and images pages are placed alongside each other and are accessible through  

 

Ones that would work for Pick n Pay

A Multi-dimensional hierarchy would work for Pick n Pay because this pattern makes use of more hierarchies which are laid over each other. This could make the shopping list simpler to navigate through.

Another pattern would be the daisy (or hub and spoke) model where the pages are interlinked on a system where you go back to the main page once you have found and placed your order.     

Further Business Objectives Analysis

A more in depth look at Pick n Pay's business objectives and whether or not they are being met or achieved effectively will inform our strategy. Correctly identifying the problems will lead to our solution.

Objective 1
Maximising profit through the provision or offering of a healthy lifestyle.
This objective is not being met because it is confusing for the user to find the information they need, the website is too cluttered and information is scattered across several URLs, therefore the information is not incorporated properly and also does not inform the design.

Objective 2
To provide a good user experience.
These objectives are not being fully met, as any confusion for the user will deter them from using the site again.

Objective 3
Finding a USP for online shopping.
We feel this objective is not being met. The things that could form their USP are not properly integrated with the online shopping website (this is the healthy lifestyle discussed in objective one).

Objective 4
Generate community envolvement and benefits.
This is not met in terms of online display/showcasing, or provision of information relating to this online is not integrated or easily located.

Objective 5
Be a sustainable business and promote environmental awareness.
This is not properly showcased online, for the same reasons as described above for other objectives not being met.

Objective 6
Create a sustainable user base (which can be achieved through updating content).
We feel they are trying to do this but the updated content is scattered and not prominent or highly visible on the page.

Tuesday, May 12, 2009

Navigation Style evaluation and examples

Navigation is a key element to any web site.

Navigation should be consistent throughout a site and should be user friendly.
The most common places to find navigation bars are the top, bottom, or left side of a page.
The right side of a page should be avoided as a navigation system, because most peoples natural eye movement is from left to right. This means that a navigation bar on the right will be difficult for the user to identify.

The size of the site and amount of information that the site contains will also have an impact on the navigation style of the site.

Agatha Taormina identifies seven main navigation styles namely; Bread crumbs, Saturation, Bottom only, Bottom with submenus, Top with submenus, Side and Side with Bottom submenus.

Bread Crumb navigation bar at the top of a page shows you where you are in a site and the site layers above your current location. Kalahari.net makes use of this effectively. Eg.
Home > Music > Music DVDs > Music DVD Topsellers.

This is a great way for the user to recall where they are in the site currently and could be used effectively by Pick n Pay as it has a large amount of stock and departments that can become overwhelming for the user.


Saturation navigation
features navigation bars on every part of the site. Top, bottom, left side - wherever a user could conceivably look. Walmart.com utilises this style of navigation as does Kalahari.

If not done correctly it can become annoying and confusing for the user, however this could be very viable for the Pick n Pay website because we could cut down on the amount of URLs currently being used.

Bottom only navigation is said to be the most common navigation bar. All of the sites that we have dealt with have a bottom navigation bar. It is often used for investor and corporate links that could clutter the othe navigation bars. This will almost certainly be used in our solution for Pick n Pay.

Bottom with submenus is an extension of the previous navigation system. It allows the users to move more freely around the site, however is more usefull for a site that utilises the bottom navigation as the primary navigation tool,

Top and Top with Submenus is quickly becoming the most popular navigation style. The Woolworths site makes use of this type of navigation with drop down menus, however for a site the size of Pick n Pay this could become very cluttered. There is a place for it as a primary navigation, however not as a secondary or tertiary navigation.

Side and Side with bottom menus is an increadibly effective navigation style for large content sites. Walmart, Amazon and Kalahari use this style in order to create easily accesable secondaty and tertiary levels without cluttering the site. The Side navigation is a great way to branch menus.

From the information gathered it looks like a well structured saturated navigation style can work for the Pick n Pay site.

Woolworths design heuristics

Heuristics for Woolworths

This is a look at the competitor Woolworths Design heuristics using the 

 Visibility of system status

The site could have considered putting a time display to show the user that the site is current recently updated. The site also doesn’t have a loading bar or page to show loading time, so the user must guess how long its going to take to get page content fully loaded.

Match between system and the real world

The system makes for more information to be available to the user that would often be hard to find in store.

User control and freedom

The user is able to look through lists of items just by doing a roll over on the main buttons. This makes it easier to find what you are looking for. There is also a quick link section that helps make it easier to find sections under the heading you've chosen. One thing that doesn’t work is the number of menu bars there are on the homepage. There are three horizontal menu bars that can confuse the user on which one is the main bar and which ones are sub-menu bars.

Consistency and standards

The site makes use of simple labels and text font for their buttons to make it simpler to communicate. They also have a quick link menu (which PnP don’t have) to show links to all the most used pages and info.  

Error prevention

The site has no errors that I could see after an hour of using it.

Recognition rather than recall

The site doesn't show any sign of remembering that I was on it. So I have to learn how to navigate through it all over again.

Flexibility and efficiency of use

Since it is quicker to find and order an item on this site, there is a good amount of efficiency. We have found through testing that it has a 3:1 click ratio to Pick n Pay. This means people are spending less time clicking through information on this site.

Aesthetic and minimalist design

The site makes use of highlighted words that link you to other bits of information. These act as extended buttons linking you to information without having to always go to the top menu buttons. This works in some instances but it is an over use of links at some areas. For instance, when you want to find out more about Credit Card Info. There is a button on the menu that takes you there, there is no need to give extra links to Credit Card info.

Help users recognize, diagnose, and recover from errors

The site makes sure that you don’t run into errors that easily. The only error recovery area I came across was when I was filling in my login info. Here when i made an error on my username, password, and account number, the site showed a footnote (text written in red) with a list of all errors made. 

Help and documentation

There is a way in which Woolworths has considered this. By showing an explanation for each of the headings you may choose to go to. When going to credit for instance, there is a box which contains details on the buttons that you are about to enter. 

PnP through Norman's 7 Principles of user design

I will be analyzing the PnP website using Norman’s 7 principles to good user interface design. These principles (developed by Donald Norman) show and evaluate ways in which the site could work better for novice and expert users. 

Visibility

The idea is to see (plain and simple) the instructions and how to go about doing the task without having to read the instructions physically. When looking for an item on the site, the viewer must be able to understand where to get the item. This means understanding that each name stands for the particular item. When looking for details on food catering for parties, I the user didn’t know that this information would be under Entertaining. It should be under Catering services or Party planning. The site should make it so that the viewer must know where to find certain sections rather than assume them. 

Feedback

Feedback on the site makes it so that the user doesn’t get stuck on what action has been taken. This is helpful when the user wants to go back on a decision or pre-determine the function before doing an action. The site has quick response when looking through the pages. 

Constraints

The scroll bar on the side of the site when looking through products becomes an immediate constraint. This puts off people because it is painstakingly long to look for a product or item when having to scroll down to the bottom of an html page. The solution would be to have a scroll down page within the main page to keep the rest of the page static, so the user doesn’t have to scroll up again.

 Natural Mapping

The site has been laid out using all-in-one user-friendly navigation structure. They put all the content on the homepage, so when clicking through different pages, the buttons and the homepage menu stays the same. 

Consistency

There is an inconsistency in the way the content is presented under the different sections. For instance, under General Merchandise is countless confusion on where to find certain products. The heading is too broad for the items under it. This heading should have been split into more than one category to clearly define the kind of items found there. There are also no images for some items on the shopping lists, and some recipes don't have an image. 

Affordability

The layout of the buttons doesn’t show that the function is to roll over the buttons for drop down menus to appear. The user has to assume that this function is available. There is also far too many menu bars which are not placed well in order of hierarchy.

Error coding

Since I never ran through any technical problems when going through the site, I believe the site has done well in keeping this problem at a minimum. 

Monday, May 11, 2009

Analysis of the Pick n Pay online site using the 10 heuristic principles

In this evaluation I will unpack whether the site is effective and where it falls short.
We will also be doing this process for a top competitors site.

1. Visibility of system status

On the Pick n Pay site I found one area when it was necessary to show the system status.
This was on the online shopping portion of the site.
Once you choose a department and the three category boxes appear a notification of loading... is shown. This is sufficient for a faster Internet connection, however on a slower connection the word loading... is not sufficient. I feel that it is not sufficient as the type and .... are stagnant. Their should be a loading bar or movement of some sort to indicate that something is happening and there is no room for concern.

There is also a lack of feedback. once you click on a department within the shopping site there is no indication that you have entered the department with the exception of the page header. This forces the user to have to remember which department they are in which is not clever design. A potential fix for this could be to utilise a breadcrumb navigation style that reminds you of the process you have gone through to get to a point. A site that uses this effectively is kalahari.net

2. Match between system and the real world

The first point that the site does not deliver on as far as what the user expects can be found on the Pick n Pay homepage. The button Kitchen leads users to a page for cooking classes and recipes. We could at a push see what the designer was thinking, however a consumer visiting a grocery stores web page will not associate these things with 'kitchen'. In the same way a person looking for cooking classes and recipes will not automatically associate kitchen with the things that they are looking for.

Secondly the navigation button order is not what the user expects. The current order is; Kitchen, About us, Investor relations, Health and nutrition, Sport, Envirozone, Shopping.
A more logical order for the user could be; Shopping, Kitchen, Health and Nutrition, Envirozone, Sport, Investor relations and About us. I feel that this is a more effective order because the primary function is shopping, then lifestyle and finally information about the company that is specifically sought by a specific type of person.

A third problem is that the navigation buttons move on a mouse over showing that they are functional, however only work if the user clicks on the type within the buttons. There is no excuse for this as all that is needed is a larger hit area.

Then there is the unforgivable mistake. The shopping button on th main navigation bar does not even take you to the online shopping portion of the site but rather to information about shopping online. The users instinct is that this button would take them to the online store.

On the online shopping portion of the site the department buttons have no synergy with the PnP homepage buttons. Users expect a site to have synergy and this is not apparent fron the department navigation bar.

3. User control and freedom

The user has the ability to control what they do on the Pick n Pay site in general, however the one thing that it lacks is an in sit back, or previous stage function. The only way to go to a previous state currently is by using the browsers back function. I feel that the inplementation of this function 'an emergency exit' could improve usability.

4. Cosistency and standards

I have covered this topic with connection of the words on the buttons kitchen, and shopping. These buttons do not meet the coventions of what the user expects. If the user has to wonder what the outcome of a click will be the designer has not done their job correctly.

One other area that this happens is where a user clicks on the flowers and gifts department. When you click on any of the other department buttons you are able to view products through the three category boxes. However with the flowers and gifts button you are sent to the netflorist site. This can interfere with a users online shopping experience and is unexpected. A fix for this would be to exclude this button from the department navigation and rather include it as an ad or link.

5. Error prevention

So far I have been unable to get an error on the site and therefore feel that currently th site has been successfull in error prevention.

6. Recognition rather than recall

The site lacks recognition on where the user has been on the site. The user is required to recall what the process is of getting to the desired product. This could be improved if their was a bar that shows you the last 10 viewed items or your most viewed items, so that you can quickly access them.

7. Flexibility and efficiency of use

Accelerators for expert users is apparent on the online shopping site. I feel that this is working to some degree as your previous shopping carts can be saved and accessed when you revisit the site making the use site better for expert users. Another function that could be used to help this process along would be to create a reoccuring shopping bag that is preordered on a weekly basis so that the user does not have to constantly place new orders.

8. Aesthetic and minimalist design

It is apparent that the designer/s have tried to create a minimalistic design however it is apparent that this has not been very successfull. Theis is alot of clutter and unessesary information on the site. For instance on the homepage for Pick n Pay their are 13 links other than the navigation buttons that pertain to many different parts of the companies offerings. This could be resolved by only including additional information thet is relevant to the portion of the site that is accessed.

The design should be consistand with the companies corporate identity. However there are too many differences between the different URLs such as the navigation bars.

9. Help users recognise, diagnose, and recover from errors.

As far as I cansee this has been done successfully. When I tried to add something to my shopping cart without being logged in I was not met eith an error code, but rather a message that stated that I needed to log in to the site or register before I could order.

10. Help and documentation

under the callcenter number there is a comprehensive instruction documentation link.

The group's plan for this week

This is a basic outline of what our group will be covering this week.

Monday
Pick 'n Pay site map
Competitor site map
Pick 'n Pay website heuristic analysis
Competitor website heuristic analysis
Pick 'n Pay user experience analysis
Brief videos depicting number of clicks to complete the same task on Pick 'n Pay and competitor websites

Tuesday
A more in depth look at Pick 'n Pay's business objectives (analysis etc)
More in depth competitor analysis (assisted by Monday's work)
Begin to develop our strategy
Compiling or grouping information for the document
Research navigation patterns

Wednesday
Strategy
Document

Thursday
Strategy
Document
Our group identity/design elements


Friday

Strategy
Document
Identity
Presentation

This contains our basic plan and further tasks may be added. The blog will be updated as each task is completed.

Sunday, May 10, 2009

Whats been happening on the weekend

To prying eyes it may seen that the blog has ground to a halt.
However this is far from reality.

We have been slaving away at creating spreadsheets of the Pick n Pay online shoppings current product categories.

On completion of this enormous task, we plan to create a more effective and user friendly organisation method for the proposed site.

Thursday, May 7, 2009

Analysis

Pick n' Pay seem to have a very green orientated site and try to show they care about the world and environment. The show they are trying to lead the way in saving energy and are doing there part in all of this yet it doesn't come through in the sire design. This is a great idea to work with today where people are more eco friendly and what to be apart of helping the environment.

Pick n' Pay does add value to customers lives on the site with their online kitchen recipes where users can look up how to make something and do it themselves. I get the feeling that they the site is trying to for a caring relationship with the user but this just doesn't come through in interaction and design where this is all content based. Nothing is reaffirmed though the site by any other medium.

Pick n' pay also have a lot to do with sport endorsement and functions that represent a healthy life style in many ways as well as being apart of the community. Again nothing is reaffirmed everything goes into it's little section which is next to something that it shouldn't be next to.

Pick n' pay is an affordable brand that is now trying to compete on a higher level. I feel that the business needs of mick n' Pay need to draw more into a greener life style of living and show this in the design. Pick n' pay has already repositioned it's home house brand where this fits in perfectly with The idea of "green" but also quality and lifestyle. All this branding does NOT come through in the website again is left with no Pick n' Pay feel to it where it has alredy started making that progression but is not communicating that online.

Pick n' pay has an online dietitian which is great for a healthy lifestyle. This is great for users who are looking at diets to loose wait or just to be healthier which almost everyone in today's society. It would be good if there was maybe an online chat where users could interact with a dietitian and get feedback unique to them making it more pesonal than just researching on what healthy.

competitor analysis

Woolworths

Woolworths have a more design oriented website in relation to Pick n' Pay. The look and feel of their website represents the brand exremely well and has that factor of a higher standard of living with quality. The architecture of the site it's self runs a lot better where tasks are easier to perform and a lot better to navigate through, where in there online shopping where it takes 3 clicks to find out a price of a product with Pick n' Pay it takes 6.
I noticed that their online store also follows their in store architecture where there are classification for example they have Woolworths food, home appliances and clothes in seperate distinct categories just like in stores where they are in separate sections.
Woolworths also have a log in screen before you start looking through the online shop which works quite well with keeping track of customers and letting them know about sales, specials etc.
Trends, lifestyle are more marketed to the market which works well with the brand it's not all over the place like Pick n' Pay.

Checkers

Low affordable prices this runs through out their site. The colours don't seem to match the brands identity seem very random and overpowering. Pick n' Pay has this same problem with the random colours that hold the headings they don't match with the brands identity and don't add anything to the site. Checkers site has better interaction with the user and easier to navigate. the one thing i noticed which was nice and could work was the drop tabs which show you what happens in each task before you go there and allows you to navigate through the site a lot more efficiently.
On the site Checkers show you that you are able to pay bills, tv license and all of those things at their stores. Pick n' Pay also has these benefits yet doesn't market it to the consumers. this could be good for the website to let people know and allow them to do it electronically when also doing their daily shopping.

ASDA

Horrible website no clue what to do do not even want to try and navigate through the site. there are too many things going on and too many buttons and options too choose from which overwhelm the customer. There is no sense of order within the site. Although it is messy they still promote a healthy lifestyle which is good. Pick n' Pay do this too but like asda it does not come through in the design and feel of the site.

Sainsbury's

Recipes are available like on the Pick n' Pay website but they allow the user too see and no thins instantly unlike Pick n' Pay where they say kitchen and you not sure what that is and could get confused with it for the online shopping. The site allows you to find the store closest to you which i thought was and could be quite useful for people who do not live in the suburbs etc. They show specials on the usual products such as milk bread which immediately comes to the users attention. The online shopping is not so good where the user can get lost very easily but at the same time you can find what you want quite easily.

Possible business objectives

Possible business objectives are:
• To increase the current percentage of users who are using the site
• Maintain an updating of content such as catalogues. (They currently have one catalogue available which is for the liquor store.)
• Clear the clutter of ads and banners on the homepage and making it look more online friendly (this looses the understanding of the site as an online shopping site. Its main mission should be to be noticed as a shopping site from first sight.)

Wednesday, May 6, 2009

Basic grocery list

I chose to do a walk through test on the Pick n Pay and Woolworths online shopping sites.
The test was to see how easily I could full my shopping cart with the items on my list.

The items I needed to purchase where: Long life, full cream milk
White sugar
Instant coffee

I measured the results based on the number of clicks needed to accomplish my task, as well as by how intuitive the actions where.


The results where as follows: On the Pick n Pay site the process took me 25 clicks.
On the Woolworths site 8 clicks.

That means that for every click on Woolworths shopping site, I clicked 3 times on the Pick n Pay site.
This in itself shows that the Pick n Pay site is not very user friendly.

Certain issues that I picked up on was that the categories on the Pick n Pay site are confusing. Milk was found in dairy and eggs, however there are categories such as milk flavourants which are deceiving.

Woolworths on the other hand makes use of drop down buttons which made the process much easier to use. However the categories are also slightly confusing and a bit of searching is required.

Another annoyance factor is that you cannot add items to your cart until you register. This is troublesome for first time users of the sites who may first want to see the ease of use before committing to registering with the site.

Online Task

This is a t A simple Task that I the user will perform on the site as a way of looking at the site's usability. the task is toShop for basic grocery items i.e. toothpaste, noodles, “Nivea for Men body wash”

Results for buying shopping item ‘Nivea for Men’ body wash.

It took me 4 clicks to get to the bathroom items section. It took a further 27 clicks to find the body wash section. After this, I clicked 4 times to get to the Shower gel, which incidentally had no image. Doing a quick search didn’t help either because the name I type: “Nivea For Men Body Wash”, wasn’t recognizable. Also there is a wide variety to choose from in the physical store, whereas on the site there is only one item to look at. 

Tuesday, May 5, 2009

Visit to the store

On my Pick n Pay store expedition my aim was to see if the store could give insights that could be incorporated online.


I found that you can pay your TV license, as well as municipality bills at the counter. This is a feature lacking online that could possibly be implemented.


I also noted that people are attracted to products visually. This is lacking on many parts of the online shopping site. If you search chocolate bars for instance there are no images available. People like to see what they are purchasing and good visuals could improve customer purchases.

Another thing I noticed was that people often read the packaging before putting an item in their trolley. The descriptions of the products online are lacking. It could be an option to include a comprehensive product description to each product similar to that on Kalahari.co.za.

I also noted the Pick n Pay radio station being played in the background. The announcer on the station would let people know what specials where on in between songs. We could possibly implement a radio stream on the online site 'with the option of turining it off of course' to allow online shoppers to engage with the brand on another level.





Pick n Pay Fresh Living magazine




I visited Pick n Pay Sunninghill today and picked up the Fresh Living magazine.

Their where one or two things that stood out.
Firstly their is an entire section dedicated to kids. This could be an avenue that we could explore for the online portion of Pick n Pay. Childrens 'nag' power has a high pull with parents. If we could get children to engage with the brand, parents may follow.

The magazine also offers coupons. What if we explored specials that are only available from interacting online?

Day Two

Tasks for day two of the brief.

Pick ‘n Pay’s business objectives:

Sales growth and profit maximization (these two can be seen as general business objectives).
Good customer relations.
Consumers engaging or interacting more with the brand.
Becoming more sustainable (environmental goals).
Social responsibility goals.
Developing their employees so they are loyal and motivated.

Are these business objectives being met by their current online strategy?

Sales growth is being increase through the online store, but there is an opportunity for further growth.
Contact numbers are provided, as well as a link to an online query form. No email address provided. The online query form has problems with the “non store related” query function. This experience can be vastly improved for the user. It is currently unknown what the Pick ‘n Pay response time is, or if they do respond, but testing this would be a good way to see if they are fulfilling their objective of good customer relations.
The website could be more interactive which will increase the consumer’s engagement with the website and the likelihood of their return to the website. Recipes and health advice form part of this strategy but it could be improved.
The “Envirozone” lays out the company’s environmental achievements, and from this information it seems it is reaching its goals in this area. A section giving tips to consumers on environmental issues might be a good idea to extend these goals beyond the company itself as well as increasing the customer’s engagement with the brand.
Social responsibility goals are not a focus on the website but descriptions can be found when going through numerous pages. The same goes for their goal of employee development. Perhaps a section for employees could be introduced.

Tasks that a Pick ‘n Pay consumer may want to complete online:

Ordering groceries for delivery (Home shopping)
Find out about Pick ‘n Pay sporting events (e.g. cycle challenge)
Send in a complaint/compliment
Look for recipes
Find out more about Pick ‘n Pay as a company

Key tasks from these options are:
Home shopping
Sending in a complaint or a compliment