Tuesday, May 12, 2009

Navigation Style evaluation and examples

Navigation is a key element to any web site.

Navigation should be consistent throughout a site and should be user friendly.
The most common places to find navigation bars are the top, bottom, or left side of a page.
The right side of a page should be avoided as a navigation system, because most peoples natural eye movement is from left to right. This means that a navigation bar on the right will be difficult for the user to identify.

The size of the site and amount of information that the site contains will also have an impact on the navigation style of the site.

Agatha Taormina identifies seven main navigation styles namely; Bread crumbs, Saturation, Bottom only, Bottom with submenus, Top with submenus, Side and Side with Bottom submenus.

Bread Crumb navigation bar at the top of a page shows you where you are in a site and the site layers above your current location. Kalahari.net makes use of this effectively. Eg.
Home > Music > Music DVDs > Music DVD Topsellers.

This is a great way for the user to recall where they are in the site currently and could be used effectively by Pick n Pay as it has a large amount of stock and departments that can become overwhelming for the user.


Saturation navigation
features navigation bars on every part of the site. Top, bottom, left side - wherever a user could conceivably look. Walmart.com utilises this style of navigation as does Kalahari.

If not done correctly it can become annoying and confusing for the user, however this could be very viable for the Pick n Pay website because we could cut down on the amount of URLs currently being used.

Bottom only navigation is said to be the most common navigation bar. All of the sites that we have dealt with have a bottom navigation bar. It is often used for investor and corporate links that could clutter the othe navigation bars. This will almost certainly be used in our solution for Pick n Pay.

Bottom with submenus is an extension of the previous navigation system. It allows the users to move more freely around the site, however is more usefull for a site that utilises the bottom navigation as the primary navigation tool,

Top and Top with Submenus is quickly becoming the most popular navigation style. The Woolworths site makes use of this type of navigation with drop down menus, however for a site the size of Pick n Pay this could become very cluttered. There is a place for it as a primary navigation, however not as a secondary or tertiary navigation.

Side and Side with bottom menus is an increadibly effective navigation style for large content sites. Walmart, Amazon and Kalahari use this style in order to create easily accesable secondaty and tertiary levels without cluttering the site. The Side navigation is a great way to branch menus.

From the information gathered it looks like a well structured saturated navigation style can work for the Pick n Pay site.

No comments:

Post a Comment